Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Omar Mejía ( hmejiag@ipn.mx ) Academic editor: Piter Boll
© 2026 Jessica Gómora-Cercas, Norberto Martínez-Méndez, Aníbal Díaz de la Vega-Pérez, Omar Mejía.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Gómora-Cercas J, Martínez-Méndez N, Díaz de la Vega-Pérez A, Mejía O (2026) The role of environmental heterogeneity in the diversity of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt. Neotropical Biology and Conservation 21(3): 223-243. https://doi.org/10.3897/neotropical.21.e187054
|
Mexico’s complex topography, variety of climates, geological history, and geographic position combine to produce heterogeneity in the amphibian fauna of biogeographic regions such as the Transmexican Volcanic Belt (TVB), a physiographic province with a semi-warm western region and a temperate eastern region. Richness, endemicity, and phylobetadiversity patterns of amphibian communities in the TVB were evaluated using different grid-cell sizes. A total of 143 species in 36 genera were studied. Species richness was higher in the eastern region than in the western region. Endemicity and phyloendemicity values were low, except in a few cells in the eastern region. The amphibian communities in the TVB comprise distinct assemblages, and biotic interactions are the primary drivers of community structure. Taxonomic and phylogenetic beta diversity indices were correlated with geographic distance, and differences in precipitation seasonality between the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) and current conditions, as well as soil temperature, were the main factors explaining species turnover. The study results confirm that environmental heterogeneity promotes high levels of taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity among the Mexican amphibian fauna. These findings may be useful in future management and conservation efforts.
Conservation, habitat filtering, overdispersion, phylobetadiversity, phylogenetic diversity, soil temperature
Biodiversity is the product of several historical and ecological factors and is commonly quantified using taxonomic richness (e.g., species or other taxonomic ranks). However, it has been demonstrated that phylogenetic diversity (PD) can be a more informative alternative to taxonomic richness, as it provides a quantitative framework for comparing biodiversity among geographic areas and clades, allowing assessment of the degree of evolutionary history shared among those areas (
Among the proposed indices to assess the PD of a region, Faith’s PD index (PD;
For example, under a phylogenetic niche conservatism scenario (
Beta (β) diversity encompasses a complex set of factors that reflect life history traits, such as reproductive strategies; ecological traits, such as vagility, niche breadth, resource use and biotic interactions; and physiographic features of the landscape, such as environmental anisotropy and geographic distance, that lead to a lack of connectivity and isolation (
The study of β diversity can be partitioned into turnover and nestedness (
Improving knowledge of the causes of diversity in highly heterogeneous regions such as Mexico is a high-priority task for conservation efforts (
The diversity of amphibians in the Transmexican Volcanic Belt (TVB) is a product of its complex geological history, its variety of climates, and its position as a transition zone between the Nearctic and Neotropical regions (
The asynchronous geological events that formed the province are reflected in a heterogeneous distribution of species richness and endemism (
Previously published studies have examined the drivers of β diversity in the Mexican amphibian fauna, but not in the TVB. For example,
Given that amphibians are small ectothermic organisms that are highly dependent on environmental humidity, the following expectations were formulated:
The study area was the TVB, as defined by
For the phylogenetic analysis, data on 1,000 species trees occurring in the TVB were downloaded from the supertree established by
The geographic space of the TVB was split using square grid cells of different sizes to incorporate geographic scale, landscape heterogeneity, and life history traits (
A presence–absence matrix was built with the fossil package 0.4.0 (
Phylogenetic community structure indices, PD, PDI, and the standardized effect size (SES) of phylogenetic diversity to eliminate the positive association between species richness and phylogenetic diversity, were estimated using the PhyloMeasures package 2.1 (
Taxonomic dissimilarity βccT (
To determine which variables could explain β-diversity patterns of the amphibian fauna of the TVB, a series of predictor variables from previous studies was used. The predictor variables were classified into three categories: contemporary bioclimatic, historical bioclimatic, and landscape variables.
Eight bioclimatic variables, BIO2 (mean diurnal range), BIO3 (isothermality), BIO6 (min temperature of coldest month), BIO12 (annual precipitation), BIO14 (precipitation of driest month), BIO15 (precipitation seasonality), BIO18 (precipitation of warmest quarter), and BIO19 (precipitation of coldest quarter) that describe trends and variation in temperature and precipitation (
Differences in four bioclimatic variables related to physiological constraints of amphibians that could limit their dispersal were evaluated: BIO4D (temperature seasonality), BIO6D (min temperature of the coldest month), BIO15D (precipitation seasonality), and BIO17D (precipitation of the driest quarter). These variables were estimated as the difference between current conditions and the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM; 21,000 years ago) using CHELSA.
Finally, seven landscape variables, geographic distance, slope, evapotranspiration rate, aridity index, NDVI (normalized difference vegetation index), soil temperature, and soil moisture, were included as predictor variables (
Potential evapotranspiration and aridity indices were downloaded from the Global Aridity Index and Potential Evapotranspiration (ET0) Database, version 3.1 (
Vegetation was quantified using NDVI derived from multispectral satellite imagery processed in GEE for the period 1990–2024 using surface reflectance imagery from Landsat 5, Landsat 7, Landsat 8, and Landsat 9 Collection 2 Level-2 products. Images were filtered to the study area and masked to remove clouds and cloud shadows using QA_PIXEL quality bands. Surface reflectance values were scaled according to Collection 2 recommendations. NDVI was calculated for each image as:
NDVI = NIR − Red/NIR + Red,
NDVI layers were clipped to the study area and exported as GeoTIFF files at 30-arc-second spatial resolution (~1 km).
Hourly ERA5-Land soil temperature data were extracted from 1 January 2001 to 31 December 2020 using the variable soil_temperature_level_2 (7–28 cm). Multi-year mean layers were computed for each depth. Surface soil moisture was estimated by integrating satellite observations from the SMAP SPL3SMP_E/005 mission and reanalysis data from ERA5-Land. Daily SMAP soil moisture data (~0–5 cm) and hourly ERA5-Land volumetric_soil_water_layer_1 data (0–7 cm) were extracted from April 2015 to December 2023. Values outside the physically plausible range of 0–0.6 m3 m-3 (
The raster files obtained were used to estimate the least-cost distances between geographic centroids in the topoDistance package 1.0.2 (
Finally, to assess whether the results were congruent with previous conservation proposals, the shapefile of Mexico’s Priority Terrestrial Conservation Areas (PCTCA;
A total of 32,038 of the 39,711 downloaded collection records for 144 species were retained after quality filtering. The order Anura included 92 species in 27 genera, the order Caudata 50 species in eight genera, and the order Gymnophiona two species in one genus. Fine-resolution grid-cell sizes (0.125°–0.375°) resulted in many empty cells or cells with only a single species, whereas coarser resolutions (0.625°–1°) poorly reflected the heterogeneity of the TVB. Therefore, results are presented only for the 0.5° grid-cell size. The remaining results are available upon request.
Species richness in the eastern region ranged from 24 to 38 species. The western region showed lower species richness, with values ranging from one to 16 species per cell (Fig.
Alpha diversity patterns of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt in grid cells of 0.5°. A. Species richness (SR); B. Phylogenetic diversity (PD); C. % of total species in the cell included in the order Anura; D. % of total species in the cell included in the order Caudata. Values were calculated individually for each cell. Priority Terrestrial Conservation Areas (PCTCA) are highlighted in green.
Endemicity patterns of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt in grid cells of 0.5°. A. Standardized phylogenetic diversity (SES); B. Endemicity index (EI); C. Phylogenetic endemism index (PE). Values were calculated individually for each cell. Priority Terrestrial Conservation Areas (PCTCA) are highlighted in green.
Values of the endemism index (EI) were low in most of the TVB, especially in the western region (EI = 0.1–6.6). Only a single cell in the eastern region had a high EI value (EI = 13.22–16.5) (Fig.
The phylogenetic diversity index (PDI) values indicate that overdispersion is the main factor shaping the phylogenetic community structure of the amphibian fauna in the TVB (Fig.
Phylogenetic community structure and taxonomic dissimilarity of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt in grid cells of 0.5°. A. Phylogenetic diversity index (PDI); B. Nearest taxon index (NTI); C. Nearest relatedness index (NRI); D. Taxonomic dissimilarity (βccT). Values were calculated individually for each cell. Priority Terrestrial Conservation Areas (PCTCA) are highlighted in green.
Most cells (69%) exhibited high values of taxonomic dissimilarity, especially in the eastern region (Fig.
β diversity patterns of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt in grid cells of 0.5°. A. Taxonomic βSOR; B. Phylogenetic phyloβSOR; C. Taxonomic turnover (βSIM); D. Phylogenetic turnover (phyloβSIM); E. Taxonomic nestedness (βNES); F. Phylogenetic nestedness (phyloβNES). Values were estimated as the average of each focal cell and its neighboring cells within a radius of 0.5°, following the procedure described by
Of the initial set of 19 explanatory variables, only eight that did not show collinearity were maintained: geographic distance, BIO6, BIO14, BIO4D, BIO15D, BIO17D, slope, and soil temperature. All variables were statistically significant (p < 0.05) after 1,000 randomizations. The amount of variance explained by the models ranged from 5.9% for both taxonomic (βNES) and phylogenetic (phyloβNES) nestedness to 25.4% for taxonomic βSOR (Table
R2 values obtained by regression analysis implemented in hier.part, relating current bioclimatic, historical bioclimatic, and landscape variables to the different facets and components of β diversity of the amphibian fauna of the Transmexican Volcanic Belt.
| βSOR | βSIM | βNES | phylo βSOR | phylo βSIM | phylo βnes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R2 | 0.254 | |0.216 | 0.059 | 0.237 | 0.198 | 0.059 |
The degree of correspondence among cells exhibiting high values of richness, phylodiversity, endemism, β diversity estimators, and the PCTCA varied markedly among the descriptors (Figs
A similar pattern was observed for endemism and phylogenetic endemism (Fig.
The amphibian species richness pattern showed a heterogeneous distribution within the TVB, with lower values in the western region and higher values in the eastern region. Several alternative scenarios could explain this pattern. Topographic and climatic complexity have been suggested as promoters of local diversity in amphibians (
An alternative explanation for the observed patterns may involve the influence of Pleistocene refugia, in which mountain systems served as transient environments that facilitated the fragmentation and isolation of species distributional ranges. This process may have been particularly important for amphibians, which are characterized by relatively low rates of climatic niche evolution (
It has been suggested that climatic niche breadth is influenced by environmental prevalence, that is, the geographic availability of particular climatic regimes throughout the evolutionary history of lineages (
Taxonomic distinctiveness was positively correlated with species richness in the TVB. It has been suggested that geographic areas with high species richness are composed of species with restricted distributions, thereby increasing taxonomic distinctiveness (
The TVB is characterized by rugged topography, which promotes sharp gradients in elevation, temperature, and precipitation. It also creates geographic barriers to dispersal, especially for taxa such as amphibians, which have low vagility and high philopatry (
In previous studies, precipitation seasonality (BIO15) has been associated with beta diversity in amphibians because highly variable precipitation can be reflected in more microhabitats, favoring species replacement through an environmental gradient, particularly in environments with temporary ponds (
The role of historical climate perturbations has rarely been explored in amphibians. However, taxonomic and phylogenetic turnover is high in regions with stable climatic conditions. These stable conditions promote specialization and reduce extinction rates. At the same time, contemporary variables act as filters, precluding dispersal from stable to unstable regions. Thus, amphibian fauna turnover is mediated by historical constraints at a broad scale and by local conditions at a local scale (
Despite the relationships found between predictor variables and various beta diversity estimators, the amount of variance explained was low. In particular, nestedness is highly dependent on several factors, such as the size of grid cells, the extent of the geographical region, and the resolution of data collection. This could be explained by several hypotheses, including selective colonization and extinction, habitat nestedness, and disturbances (
Further research is needed to evaluate the effects of other variables, such as landscape connectivity (
Altitudinal range could limit amphibian dispersal and greatly affect species replacement and nestedness due to weaker competitive exclusion and stronger habitat filtering (
Finally, although functional diversity was not evaluated directly, the results of this study could serve as a proxy for characterizing it, given the expectation that cells with high values of alpha and beta phylogenetic diversity will, in most cases, exhibit different functional traits. Thus, high values of phylobetadiversity turnover could suggest functional turnover and a high number of strategies (
The high dissimilarity among cells observed herein suggests that each cell harbors unique lineages that are important for conserving phylogenetic diversity. This poses a key challenge to preserving the evolutionary history of these species assemblages (
There is no clear consensus on the criteria for establishing biological conservation areas. In practice, natural protected areas are often designed according to non-biological criteria, including aesthetic value or their location in little-impacted areas (
Phylogenetic diversity has emerged as a descriptor for conservation planning because it incorporates both species richness and rarity (
A recent study evaluating the aforementioned facets of diversity revealed that 90% of Mexico’s mammal species are distributed within protected areas and that most of the remaining species belong to taxa with low dispersal abilities, such as rodents (
This lack of congruence is particularly concerning for a taxonomic group that is highly sensitive to anthropogenic disturbances, especially within the TVB (
Species richness, endemism, and phylogenetic endemism of the amphibian fauna in the TVB are higher in the eastern region, which is characterized by temperate, subhumid climates and harbors greater caudate diversity. Most community assemblages are structured by phylogenetic overdispersion, with habitat filtering explaining only a small proportion of the variation in grid cells. The TVB exhibits high levels of both taxonomic and phylogenetic beta diversity, coupled with low nestedness. Geographic distance and soil temperature emerged as the main drivers shaping amphibian diversity patterns. Finally, most facets of biodiversity showed limited spatial overlap with the current priority conservation areas established under Mexican legislation, highlighting the complexity of conserving this biologically vulnerable group.
This work is part of the first author’s Master’s thesis. The authors also acknowledge Irene Goyenechea, Rocío Demartín, Liliana Saboyá, and the associate editor Piter Boll for their useful comments, which helped improve the manuscript.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.
No AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.
JGC acknowledges SECIHTI for the student grant received.
Conceptualization: OM, NMM. Data curation: JGC, ADVP. Formal analysis: JGC, OM. Investigation: NMM. Methodology: JGC, NMM. Project administration: OM. Supervision: ADVP, OM, NMM. Writing – original draft: JGC. Writing – review and editing: OM, NMM, ADVP.
J. Gómora-Cercas https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6675-2737
A. Díaz de la Vega-Pérez https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5651-4383
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.