Research Article |
Corresponding author: Ricardo Villalba-Briones ( rvillalba@espol.edu.ec ) Academic editor: João Pompeu
© 2023 Ricardo Villalba-Briones, Paolo Michael Piedrahita, Daniel Omar Garces, Juan S. Monrós.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Villalba-Briones R, Piedrahita PM, Garces DO, Monrós JS (2023) Sensitisation, research and management for conservation within ESPOL University forests after the COVID-19 pandemic, Ecuador. Neotropical Biology and Conservation 18(4): 283-303. https://doi.org/10.3897/neotropical.18.e110615
|
Non sustainable land uses are disturbing natural habitats and wild animals’ ecology worldwide. Nevertheless, the sensitisation of key actors combined with research and a consequent management can influence decision-making and improve animals’ well-being. COVID-19 has influenced the number of interactions with wildlife in urban environments and the ESPOL Polytechnic University is a university campus that holds forested areas in Guayaquil, Ecuador. We implemented an environmental education course with an empathetic approach for the security guards of the university. We used questionnaires to evaluate their attitudes and knowledge on wildlife before and after the sensitisation course. In addition, we registered the incidences of native fauna resulting from the guards’ collaborations and we designed management strategies according to the data gathered. The guards showed an improvement in their knowledge of the issues covered (n = 81–87; X̄ = 163.4%) and an increased preference for wild and native fauna after the sensitisation course (n = 67; 151.6%). Furthermore, the collaborations of guards with the Biodiversity Unit of the university concerning animal-human interactions increased, as did the supporting actions towards the well-being of native animals. Moreover, the information about direct and indirect interactions with wildlife included reports on traces of large to medium animal activity and a record of illegal hunting of Choloepus hoffmanni for bushmeat consumption. Obtained data sustained adaptive management actions such as signalling and restrictions in use. We recommend educating key actors with an empathetic approach, developing critical skills and promoting collaborations to reduce human impacts in wild areas.
Awareness, citizen-science, empathy, environmental education, management, Puma concolor
To achieve conservation goals and ensure the sustainable use of the landscape, protected area management needs to consider natural values, key actors and land use (
Environmental education aims to develop awareness about nature, increase knowledge and promote positive attitudes that will influence protective behaviour and social norms (
Large animals, especially mammals, are usually the most appreciated animals for adults and children (
Cycling and, to a lesser extent, the presence of hikers in natural environments, negatively impacts wildlife (
In this work, we present the results of research that prompted the implementation of adaptive management actions in two areas, BPP and Parcón, considering sensitisation of key actors, wildlife research, citizen-science and collaboration with local authorities.
ESPOL Polytechnic University’s (2°08'55.21"S, 79°57'52.20"W) urban area is protected by private security guards who underwent a sensitisation course with an empathetic approach for the conservation of native fauna (
The course involved sharing knowledge on the characteristics of native charismatic mammalian species in the local conservation context, highlighting ecological and ethological perspectives (Fig.
Apart from general characteristics, the course also promoted the identification of native charismatic species and their traces and linked this information with their daily activities (
After the sensitisation course, collaboration in management actions were encouraged and guidelines were described. Consequently, in collaboration with local environmental authorities (MAATE- acronym for Ministry of Environment, Water and Ecological Transition in Spanish, and UPMA- acronym for National Police for Protection of Environment Police in Spanish) and the Biodiversity Unit constituted by the Faculty of Life Sciences (ESPOL University), the guards assisted in conservation activities, such as wildlife releases, rescues and security issues during research activities inside ESPOL. Location of the incidences were illustrated in maps designed using ArcGIS pro version 3.1 for posterior analysis.
In this study an R-studio platform (
The results of the evaluation on identification capacity of mammals native to the BPP (predators, footprints and primates) showed an increase in all issues after the sensitisation course (Fig.
The normality of the data was tested and all results, except for the before course results on predators and sloths (W = 0.97, p-value = 0.08; W = 0.98, p-value = 0.1) showed no normality (p < 0.05).
The Wilcoxon test showed that data groups before and after were significantly different in their evaluation results about primates, carnivores and sloths (V = 341, p-value = 7.4e-9; V = 132.5, p-value = 8.2e-11; V = 3.5, p-value = 6.3e-16). Knowledge on native species increased significantly before and after the course amongst guards in all the topics evaluated (primates = 128.73%; predators = 178.43%; sloths = 183.04%) (n = 81; 82; 87, respectively) (Fig.
Sixty-seven participants successfully filled out the questionnaire about animal preferences (free response; a total of three species) before and after the course and fourteen participants did not change their responses. In the questionnaire before the course, from the species covered, just the cougar and just once, was selected as a favourite species. On the other hand, after the course, all the species were selected as favourites at least once summing to twenty-one mentions in total (cougar and jaguar were the most popular species, with seven and six mentions, respectively).
Wild species were 151.6% times selected after the course and native species 142.9%, which indicates an increase in appreciation of wild and native species (Fig.
Regarding to primate emotion interpretation questionnaires, after the course 35.8% of participants improved previous results, 24.7% were worse and 39.5% obtained the same results (n = 81). Overall, the results only reached 108.3% of their initial values. The age and results data did not follow a normal distribution (p < 0.05), Spearman’s rank analysis showing no correlation between age and the questionnaire results (p = 0.63).
From the two reports done three years before the sensitisation course, there were fourteen cases reported by guards during the following 10 months of activity (Table
Security guards’ reports list on incidence and management actions related to wildlife within ESPOL University territorial limits, Guayaquil, Ecuador.
Year | Month | Species | Type of report | Conflict | Management action |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018 | - | Tamandua mexicana | Possible rescue | Road interference | Translocation to another forest area |
2019 | - | Choloepus hoffmanni | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch |
2022 | February | Choloepus hoffmanni | Possible rescue | Contact with power line | Translocation to another forest area |
March | Choloepus hoffmanni | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch | |
June | Tamandua mexicana with a juvenile | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch | |
July | Choloepus hoffmanni | Rescue | Illegal hunting activity | Transport to a rehabilitation centre and subsequent release after treatment | |
August | Boa constrictor | Rescue | Road interference | Translocation to another forest area | |
August | Sciurus stramineus | Reported dead | Traffic collision | Safe disposal of the corpse | |
August | Tamandua mexicana | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch | |
September | Tamandua mexicana | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch | |
October | Choloepus hoffmanni | Possible rescue | Road interference | Translocation to another fore | |
October | Tamandua mexicana | Reported dead | Possible mountain bike collision | Safe disposal of the corpse | |
October | Eira barbara | Presence mentioned | None | None | |
October | Mazama americana | Presence mentioned | None | None | |
October | Sciurus stramineus | Possible rescue | Road interference | Follow-up to forest patch | |
November | Didelphis marsupialis | Reported dead and rescue | Human conflict | Safe disposal of the corpse and Ministry of Environment technicians rescue of juveniles |
Most of the detections of wild fauna (11/16) were performed in areas close to roads and in urbanised areas from the ESPOL University (Fig.
Map showing the presence of fauna based on reports from guards before (*) and after the training curse of the ESPOL private guards A Choloepus hoffmanni capitalis B Boa constrictor C Tamandua mexicana D Didelphis marsupialis E Sciurus stramineus F Mazama americana G Eira barbara. Authors: Daniel Garces and Ricardo Villalba-Briones. Photographic source: R. Villalba-Briones (ESPOL Campus Gustavo Galindo) (A, C, F), Rodolfo Gil (Mansión Mascota) (B, D, E), Roger Valencia (Guayaquil) (G).
Field research related to guards’ activity in collaboration with the university researchers revealed two areas with the presence of large to medium-sized species from the Carnivora order. Vocalisations (Fig.
Indirect records of predation and resting places inside ESPOL University territorial limits A Prosperina Protector Forest resting place of large-size mammal B Parcón area Puma concolor suspected footprints recorded by the ESPOL guards C Parcón area frontal 6 cm Eira barbara footprint near lake mud, phalange paw trace 2.5 cm long, 1.2 cm wide D crawfish head visible at three metres from a burrowed area on predation activity near a Eira barbara footprint. Source: I. Ugalde, R. Villalba-Briones.
After a guard’s guidance heading to a suspected felid footprint (Fig.
During the nocturnal follow-up of a released two-toed sloth, a bulk of feathers was found displaced in the same 50 cm diameter ground and urine markings were noted. Two camera traps were placed near the area after slightly clearing it and, after around two hours, two types of predator vocalisations were perceived at approximately 50 m distance (Fig.
Regarding to recorded vocalisations in the field, first, a series of “yowl” calls were recorded (V1), which then changed into “ouch” calls (V2). An analysis of the V1 call’s sound spectrum showed a 3.8 sec of duration and ranged from 430 to 312 Hz with a dominant frequency of around 400 Hz (Fig.
During reported footprint revision, non-regulated itineraries that disrupted the continuity of the forest were registered. At that moment, twenty cycling itineraries had been declared inside the ESPOL limits. Due to the extension of the 570 ha forest, it was considered detrimental for the conservation of large animals of great ecological importance, such as native ungulates and wild cats (
Based on the information gathered after consulting with groups of interest from the ESPOL University, such as the Sustainability and Biodiversity Unit, the importance of the BPP core area (CA) and Parcón CA were identified and management measures (Fig.
The sensitisation course improved the willingness to help and positively encouraged guards towards conservation, leading to better communication and a more effective management of the area. By explaining the animals’ life and dramas, the listeners can relate not only to their challenges, but also to the animal emotions, fostering an empathetic perspective (
The COVID-19 pandemic severely limited public access to the area within ESPOL University, resulting in a quieter and more gentle environment for wildlife. Consequently, it is probable that the wildlife has increased the exploratory use of the ESPOL forest and urban areas during the lockdown within the university´s territorial limits, as it has been observed in other countries (
Previous works have documented threats, such as low guttural growls, when approaching Puma concolor individuals as experienced by the researcher (R. V-B.) (
Water bodies are an essential resource for wildlife that gains relevance during the dry season (
Large predator populations are declining around the world under the pressure of anthropogenic impacts, such as direct extirpation or habitat destruction, resulting in severe effects on other species and ecosystem services (
Cycling is an activity that can have a significant impact on natural areas and can be minimised through appropriate management (
Awareness raising activities focused on animal species conservation contribute to the survival of individuals of native species on the ground. We recommend incorporating empathy-based strategies in environmental education and sensitisation activities to encourage conservation attitudes. At the same time, lecturing about local species diversity and techniques to identify them through animal traces promotes a citizen-based wildlife surveillance, helps in establishing protocols and improvement of competences on conservation actions. Interestingly, in our work, these activities resulted in a predominantly static monitoring activity conducted by security guards, which ultimately led to research and management actions.
There are large and medium-sized mammals of interest inhabiting BPP and Parcón forest areas and there is a need for active management implementation. The water systems and forests from the Parcón area and the BPP comprise essential areas for the fauna and should be protected actively. Investment in active surveillance of natural areas is recommended to avoid interferences with the native wildlife, considering the most remarkable areas as Parcón CA and the BPP CA shown in the map (Fig.
In its protected forest condition, the BPP protects the fauna and flora within its boundaries, but other natural areas with high ecological value should also be considered. Constraining disruptive activities is a valuable option when protecting wildlife is prioritised. Therefore, we recommend BPP CA and Parcón CA to be actively protected due to their essential function of providing water and food to wild animals and to maintain management actions, including entry restriction to minimise human presence. We also recommend further non-invasive research using camera traps, collaboration with key stakeholders for implementing protection strategies and expanding surveillance and patrolling efforts.
We would like to thank ESPOL University and especially to the Sustainability Unit, M. Sc. Andrea Reyes and M. Sc. Edwin Jimenez for their support, Ivan Ugalde, Jimmy Estevez and the private security guards from the ESPOL for their trust and collaboration in the protection of wild animals, to the students Carla Freire, Julio Coloma, Leonor Rivera, Maria Pia Beltran, Derly Mieles and Daniela Coronel for their role in the sensitisation course, to David Webb from the UK Otter Wild Trust, Galo Zapata from Wildlife Conservation Society and Domingo Ankwash from Cordillera del Cóndor Shuar indigenous tribe for their advice and Mansion Mascota, Ministry of Water, Environment and Ecological Transition and Environmental Police of the Guayaquil Council for their help in the rescue, rehabilitation and release of animals in the forested areas of the ESPOL University.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
ESPOL University supported the research and publication of this work through Sustainability Unit and Life Sciences Faculty's resources.
Conceptualization: RVB. Data curation: RVB. Formal analysis: DOG, RVB. Funding acquisition: RVB. Investigation: JSM, PMP, RVB. Methodology: DOG, JSM, RVB. Project administration: RVB. Resources: RVB. Software: RVB, DOG. Supervision: JSM, RVB. Validation: DOG, JSM, PMP. Visualization: RVB. Writing – original draft: RVB. Writing – review and editing: JSM, RVB, PMP.
Ricardo Villalba-Briones https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5577-1705
Paolo Michael Piedrahita https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4403-6326
Daniel Omar Garces https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7774-4409
Juan S. Monrós https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0952-2089
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
ESPOL Universities Ethical Committee aprobation of the study
Data type: pdf
Explanation note: The committee analized the procedures of the sensitization activity and approved the activity data protection and publication of the results in a scientific article.
Autorización de recoleccion de especimenes de especies de la diversidad biologica No. 2174
Data type: pdf
Explanation note: Permit to recollect samples and create sinergyc actions with wildlife rehabillitation centres for conservation in the Guayas Province from the environmental guvernamental institution of Ecuador, the MAATE (Ministry of Environment, Water, and Ecologic Transition of Ecuador).
Data from questionnaires to asses effectivity of the sensitization course
Data type: xlsx
Explanation note: The excel archive shows the results of the guards answering information related to native fauna. The archive show the results before and after the course of senzitization.